Skip to content
Menu
Campaign Buyer Best of

A switching guide formedia buyer software

GemPages alternatives

By Dana Rourke, Lead Reviewer. Reviewed by Campaign Buyer Editorial. Updated 8 September 2026.

You already know what GemPages does. The question is what to run instead, and why. We read what long-term users report about the tools below and checked each vendor's own documentation and pricing, then ranked them by the reasons buyers actually switch: price, a missing capability, or a better fit for your traffic.

Still comparing? Read our full GemPages review first, then come back to these.

The GemPages home page, captured from the vendor's own site, headed "Conversion-focused Page Builder for Shopify Stores".
GemPages, the tool these alternatives are weighed against.

Quick answer

The best alternative to GemPages is Replo. Replo is the pick if you send paid traffic to a Shopify store and test the pages yourself. Starter covers that job. Pro is for a brand that also wants Replo's team to set up the account. The pages can get heavy on a phone.

The shortlist

  1. 1. Replo is the best GemPages alternative for shopify DTC brands scaling paid ads who want AI-assisted pages, analytics, and split-URL tests.
  2. 2. PageFly is the best GemPages alternative for shopify merchants who want drag-and-drop pages with built-in A/B tests and heatmaps on the store domain.
  3. 3. Shogun is the best GemPages alternative for established Shopify stores that need unlimited pages and MTU-based A/B tests.

Compared at a glance

Feature comparison across 3 tools
Tool A/B testing Analytics Free plan Templates From
1. Replo Split-URL tests via dedicated link (default reploedge.com); Shopify store URLs cannot be the test entry point –Unknown ✓Yes –Unknown Free tier
2. PageFly Optimize plan and above; Bayesian models; 3 concurrent tests on Optimize –Unknown –Unknown 320+ page and section templates Free tier
3. Shogun Included on paid plans; MTU caps apply –Unknown Draft only, no publishing –Unknown Free tier

The alternatives, ranked

1. Replo

Best GemPages alternative for shopify DTC brands scaling paid ads who want AI-assisted pages, analytics, and split-URL tests

The Replo home page, captured from the vendor's own site
Replo, our number 1 GemPages alternative.

Replo is the pick if you send paid traffic to a Shopify store and test the pages yourself. Starter covers that job. Pro is for a brand that also wants Replo's team to set up the account. The pages can get heavy on a phone.

What works

  • Built for direct-response Shopify stores: it reads live product and cart data, so an advertorial or listicle page links straight into native checkout
  • Split tests and analytics ship inside the tool, and the test links keep your UTMs intact so Meta and Google attribution survives the experiment
  • Campaign pages are fast to build, so a buyer can test a new angle this week without waiting on an engineer

What to watch

  • The most expensive Shopify page builder in this set. A custom domain is included on the paid plans.
  • Buyers say the design is strong, but the pages are script-heavy. Buyers complain about slow load times on a phone.
  • The A/B test runs on a separate subdomain, so running ads needs an extra setup step before the test can use the store's own address.

Read the full Replo review.

2. PageFly

Best GemPages alternative for shopify merchants who want drag-and-drop pages with built-in A/B tests and heatmaps on the store domain

The PageFly home page, captured from the vendor's own site
PageFly, our number 2 GemPages alternative.

PageFly is the pick if you run a smaller Shopify store, want a capable builder for a low monthly price, and only need a handful of pages live at once. It is the most-installed builder in the category. The catch is the published-page limit on cheaper plans and the front-end weight it adds.

What works

  • Cheap to start: plans open at $24/mo, and a free tier covers a single published page
  • The most-reviewed builder on the Shopify App Store, so templates, guides and support answers are easy to find
  • Flexible drag-and-drop that handles product detail pages, offers and theme sections without code

What to watch

  • Lower plans cap how many pages stay published at once, and buyers report hitting that ceiling after launch as a forced upgrade
  • In a public before-and-after test it added the heaviest payload of the builders measured, near 350 KB and several hundred milliseconds of mobile load
  • Testing and analytics are thinner than Replo's, so heavy experimenters outgrow it

Read the full PageFly review.

3. Shogun

Best GemPages alternative for established Shopify stores that need unlimited pages and MTU-based A/B tests

The Shogun home page, captured from the vendor's own site
Shogun, our number 3 GemPages alternative.

Shogun is the pick if you are an established store with a content team that wants shared sections and structured page operations, and you can absorb a $199 or $499 plan for the real features. Its weak point is the editor, which buyers repeatedly describe as painfully slow to work in.

What works

  • Shared page blocks, saved versions and an approval step suit a team publishing many pages against one store
  • A long track record and a large review base on the Shopify App Store
  • You can build a page in the free draft mode before you commit to a paid plan

What to watch

  • The editor is the recurring gripe: buyers call it unbearably slow to build in, enough that some revert to plain Shopify pages
  • The useful tiers jump to $199 and $499/mo, well above PageFly for a comparable job
  • Older feedback flags the same front-end weight the category is known for, and that it injects its own tracking pixel

Read the full Shogun review.

How we evaluated these

We ranked these using the same rubric as the incumbent: we read what long-term users report about each one, checked its documentation and pricing, and verified prices with the vendor before reaching a verdict. The order shows which option fits the largest group of GemPages users. Where an alternative wins only for a specific traffic source or team size, we say so on that card. Our methodology page sets out the full process.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to GemPages?
Replo comes first in our ranking, with PageFly second.
Why look for an alternative to GemPages?
Buyers mostly switch over cost, a feature the tool lacks, or traffic it handles badly. Each pick on this page names why it wins and what it gives up.

Sources

Other sources

7 discussions and reviews read for this page. Quotes are excerpts; open a link to read the original in context.

  1. [r-reasonable] Best shopify page builder app? Reddit,
  2. [r-avoid] Best shopify page builder app? Reddit,
  3. [r-instant] Anyone tried Replo? Reddit,
  4. [r-liquid] Convert Replo page to Shopify Liquid Reddit,
  5. [sas-price] Replo reviews page 14 Blog,
  6. [sas-pos] Replo Shopify App Store reviews Blog,
  7. [sas-neg] Replo Shopify App Store reviews Blog,
GemPages review Best Shopify landing page builder ranking Every review Head-to-heads
Dana Rourke

Written by

Dana Rourke

Lead Reviewer

Dana Rourke is the lead reviewer at Campaign Buyer. She covers trackers and attribution on this site: she reads what long-term users report about each tool, checks its documentation and pricing, and verifies prices with the vendor before writing the verdict. Keeping the rankings honest mostly means writing down what the top pick gets wrong, so she does that first.

danar@campaignbuyer.com

Last checked 2026-09-08

Comments

No comments yet. Questions and your own experience are welcome.

Leave a comment

Thank you. Your comment will appear once it has been reviewed.